Unmarked Grave

Tutors usually put a card in your hand; this one puts it in your graveyard, and that inversion is the entire point. For decks that want a specific card in the yard rather than the hand (reanimation targets, delve fodder, flashback and escape payloads, or a creature to bring back cheaply), the graveyard is a resource you were going to fill anyway, so paying two mana to pick the exact card that lands there is closer to a self-mill Demonic Tutor than to a discard outlet. The nonlegendary clause is the restriction that pays for the flexibility: you cannot fetch the format-warping legend directly, which keeps the effect pointed at the fat reanimation payloads and enablers that read as nonlegendary by default. It answers a long-standing awkwardness in graveyard strategies, which historically leaned on random discard, dredge, or brute-force self-mill and prayed the key piece ended up in the bin. Here the selection is deterministic: name the card, shuffle, and cast whatever bridges the yard to the battlefield next. The rate is unassuming precisely because the value shows up a turn later, when the reanimation spell or delve threat resolves off a graveyard you engineered rather than one you hoped for.