Hunted by The Family

Villainous choice exists to make punisher effects genuinely punishing: instead of the caster dictating which downside to inflict, the target's own controller picks the outcome, and the design's job is to build both branches so either answer costs them something real. This spell weaponizes that structure four times over. For each targeted creature, its controller decides between watching it shrivel into a vanilla 1/1 white Human with every ability stripped away, or handing the caster a full copy of it. Neither branch is safe: pick the first, and their threat survives as a toothless blank body, still theirs but useless; pick the second, and the caster now fields a duplicate of their best creature, complete with whatever enters-the-battlefield triggers that copy fires on arrival. The decision splits by what the creature is worth. A commander or a value engine tends to get flattened, because gifting a copy of it to the opponent is unthinkable; a modest body, or one whose stats matter more than any single ability, is the safer thing to let the caster copy. Seven mana at sorcery speed is the ceiling that keeps a four-target swing in check, and any copies land under the caster's control immediately. Its teeth come from volume: it forces up to four separate lose-lose decisions in a single resolution, and the players making them are never the one who cast the spell.