Skip to content
Moxonomy

Cruel Grimnarch

Creature — Phyrexian Cleric5 generic manaBlack mana

The enters trigger is where this Cleric reveals it was built for a full pod, not a duel. A 5/5 with deathtouch for six is a fine top-end body, trading up or down in combat and daring anything to block. But the ability sizes itself to the table: each opponent discards a card of their own choosing, and for every opponent who has none to lose, four life comes back to you instead. This is hand-attrition that scales with head count, and a cushion against the players who would rather empty their hands early: aggressive decks, storm shells, hellbent black. It solves the perennial problem for a grinding discard effect, which is what a hand-attack trigger does when an opponent is already hellbent and has nothing to throw away. The life is not a drain (the opponent loses nothing), and it is not a choice you or they make; it is the conditional payoff that keeps the trigger from ever whiffing. That conditionality is the design discipline: an opponent with cards feeds your hand-attrition plan, an opponent without them feeds your life total, and neither outcome leaves the six mana doing nothing. Deathtouch on a large body is the incidental part; the discard-per-opponent-or-life-per-empty-opponent structure, scaling with the number of players across the table, is why the card exists.

Cruel Grimnarch (one)
ONE · #88common
Pricing
Normal: $0.24
Foil: $0.07
Oracle Text

Rules text

Deathtouch When this creature enters, each opponent discards a card. For each opponent who can't, you gain 4 life.
Legalities

Format Status

Standard
N/A
Pioneer
Legal
Modern
Legal
Legacy
Legal
Vintage
Legal
Commander
Legal
Pauper
Legal
Brawl
Legal
Historic
Legal
Alchemy
N/A
Timeless
Legal
Standard Brawl
N/A
More formats
Old School
N/A
Premodern
N/A
PreDH
N/A
Pauper Commander
Legal
Oathbreaker
Legal
Gladiator
Legal
Penny Dreadful
N/A
Duel Commander
Legal
Future Standard
N/A
COMPETITIVEBRAWL
Legal
TLR
N/A
Quick navigation
move selectesc close