Skip to content
Moxonomy

Bone Shredder

Creature — Phyrexian Minion2 generic manaBlack mana

Strip away the keyword and what you have is Nekrataal stapled to a flier: a 1/1 for 2 generic manaBlack mana that destroys target nonartifact, nonblack creature the instant it lands. The body is irrelevant. You are buying the kill, and the price tag is honest because echo bills you again to keep the creature past your next upkeep. The default arc is simple: it lands, it kills, and unless you pay 2 generic manaBlack mana a second time, it dies on schedule. That tax is the balancing weight on a removal rate that would otherwise be undercosted, and the design assumes most pilots will let the 1/1 expire rather than re-buy it. The sleight is that the destroy clause keys to the creature entering, not to surviving. The echo cost is optional, and the correct shell never pays it. Bounce it, blink it, or sacrifice it before upkeep and it re-enters, re-triggering the kill, while the new object's echo can simply be declined to let it die again. Echo on its own is a mana tax that forces a sacrifice; wrapped in flicker or recursion, that downside inverts into a loop that re-runs targeted removal every cycle and declines the tax entirely. That is the structural lesson worth keeping: a genuine cost printed on the card that the right pilot simply refuses to pay, and the kill keeps coming.

Bone Shredder (dde)
DDE · #5uncommon
Pricing
Normal: $0.21
Foil:
Oracle Text

Rules text

Flying Echo 2 generic manaBlack mana (At the beginning of your upkeep, if this came under your control since the beginning of your last upkeep, sacrifice it unless you pay its echo cost.) When this creature enters, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature.
Legalities

Format Status

Standard
N/A
Pioneer
N/A
Modern
Legal
Legacy
Legal
Vintage
Legal
Commander
Legal
Pauper
N/A
Brawl
N/A
Historic
N/A
Alchemy
N/A
Timeless
N/A
Standard Brawl
N/A
More formats
Old School
N/A
Premodern
Legal
PreDH
Legal
Pauper Commander
N/A
Oathbreaker
Legal
Gladiator
N/A
Penny Dreadful
N/A
Duel Commander
Legal
Future Standard
N/A
COMPETITIVEBRAWL
N/A
TLR
Legal
Printings elsewhere

Other printings

5 sets
Quick navigation
move selectesc close